All

Fundraising Report Card

Fundraising Report Card

Rebuilding a free legacy tool into a strategic SaaS platform

Client:

MarketSmart

When:

Q1 2025 - Q3 2025

Stage:

Established company

Role:

Product Director

Illustration of an open hand beneath a heart

MarketSmart helps nonprofits raise more money through data-driven tools and services. Its Fundraising Report Card turns donation data into the fundraising performance metrics, dashboards, and reports nonprofit professionals use to see how they are doing and where to focus.

MarketSmart helps nonprofits raise more money through data-driven tools and services. Its Fundraising Report Card turns donation data into the fundraising performance metrics, dashboards, and reports nonprofit professionals use to see how they are doing and where to focus.

SITUATION

The Fundraising Report Card had what most products never get: users who loved it. Nonprofits around the world relied on it, retention was strong, and consultants were asking to pay for a premium version.

But the effort to rebuild it for scale had stalled. Months of work with an external development shop had produced motion without a foundation, and the path from free tool to paid platform was unproven. MarketSmart brought me in as product director to take over the product and get the rebuild moving in the right direction.

APPROACH

I worked in four steps.

Discovery: find the North Star. I started with user interviews and a deep dive into the company’s existing research to answer one question: what job do nonprofits actually hire this product to do? The answer reframed the work. Development directors did not need prettier charts; they needed to make confident fundraising decisions. That shifted the product from a reporting tool toward decision intelligence, and gave every later decision a test.

Mapping: rebuild the foundation before accelerating. Early on I dug into the CRM and database foundations with engineering, so the rebuild would rest on known ground. The roadmap became a sequence of proof points, ordered so the riskiest assumptions got tested first.

Monetization: design the path from free to paid. I proposed an activation journey built on the product’s natural hook: see your peer benchmarks free, connect your data, see how your organization ranks, then upgrade for ongoing insights. On pricing, I brought willingness-to-pay discipline (what is it worth to save hours on this task, and where does this sit in your budget) rather than asking people to price features they cannot value.

Execution: one framework, one rhythm. I aligned the internal team and the external development shop on a single prioritization lens: jobs to be done, chosen because a development director’s world runs on quarterly board cycles, not daily habits. A feedback group of fundraising professionals shaped and tested new designs as we redesigned and shipped dozens of features.

OUTCOMES

The engagement left the product with a clear direction and a team that could run with it.

  • Repositioned a free legacy tool as a strategic SaaS platform, with a clear North Star and a monetization path.

  • Ran user research across 100+ users, turning anecdote into segmented insight the whole team could build from.

  • Redesigned and shipped dozens of features with the internal team and the external development shop.

  • Ran a user experience feedback group of fundraising professionals, recruited through a public campaign, to shape and test the new designs.

  • Closed out with a structured handoff: a wrap-up with the CEO, and analytics instrumentation (Amplitude) in place for the internal team.

I wrote up this three-phase approach the week the engagement began: From Stagnant 1.0 to Scalable 2.0.

PRODUCT

Fundraising Report Card donations dashboard with giving levels by month

The redesigned donations view: total giving by month, broken out by giving level.

[ CONNECT ]

Let’s talk

Get in touch

© 2026 Howard & Agnes, LLC

[ CONNECT ]

Let’s talk

Get in touch

© 2026 Howard & Agnes, LLC